I’m a die hard cat fanatic. If you tell me that X number of cats is too many, I’ll probably cheerfully tell you that you can never have too many cats then start rambling about my dream of one day having a home with cats numbering in the dozens, if not hundreds. But seriously, how many cats is too many cats, and when does an abnormal love of cats turn into an unhealthy love of cats?
Well, it depends
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the question of how many cats is too many. The right number of cats for any person (or rescue or shelter for that matter) is going to depend on their resources, commitment and passion as well as the cats themselves. For some, 50 cats might be a very comfortable number, for others, two cats might be one too many.
Ask your cats
The cats in your household will play a big part in determining the right number of cats for you.
Cats are social creatures by nature. While they hunt independently and don’t naturally form packs, feral cats do live in colonies, rather than as solitary animals. As such, most cats will adapt well to sharing a house with other cats.
Intact cats are more inclined to territorial behaviour like marking with urine/feces or fighting, so spaying and neutering our cats makes for huge improvements in increasing harmony in a multi-cat household (as well as avoiding unwanted kittens, also very important.)
Unfortunately, some cats just do not like other cats, period. An adjustment period where the hierarchy gets sorted out is normal after adding a new cat to the home, but some cats would truly be better off being an only-cat. Forcing these types of cats to share a house with other cats can be a huge source of stress for everyone. Solitary cats in multi-cat households often vent their stress on other cats through fighting, stalking and unprovoked attacks, which is not good for any of the cats involved, and will often mark territory with urine and feces, which is a big stress for you, the cat owner.
Providing enough territory
It probably sounds obvious, but you can comfortably house more cats in a large home than in a small one. The amount of available territory is an important factor in determining the right number of cats. There should be enough space in your home to allow each cat their own space, where they can get away from all the other cats. Overcrowding isn’t good for anyone.
Giving your cats access to the outdoors can increase available territory, though it’s important to consider the health and safety risks faced by outdoor cats. Also, if you live in a place with harsh winters your cats may all be inclined to stay inside during the coldest months anyway. Groups of cats who quite comfortably share a yard and house during the summer can get cooped up and cranky during the winter months when everyone is staying inside and conflicts can increase.
When looking at the available territory in your house, keep in mind that cat territory not only includes horizontal space (floor space) but also vertical space (furniture, shelves, cat trees, window ledges etc.) Even if the square footage of your home is small, territory can be increased by adding vertical territory, such as wall mounted shelves, windowsill platforms, cat trees and other cat furniture, making it easier for everyone to live in harmony.
If you have lots of space and spare rooms, you can keep groups of cats separate to reduce territory conflicts. Fluffy, Muffin and Spot might all get along with each other but not with Ginger and Toby. Using physical barriers to prevent territory overlap can make for a much more peaceful home.
Living within your means
As a responsible cat owner, your financial situation is pretty important in determining how many cats you can keep.
Not only must you be able to provide day to day care in the form of quality food, litter, toys and treats, it’s important that you be financially prepared to provide routine vet care such as spay/neuter, vaccinations and deworming, and emergency veterinary care for unexpected illness or injury.
If you have limited finances and aren’t able to put away savings or buy pet insurance, it may still be possible to come up with the funds to handle a single cat emergency. For a multi-cat household, it’s important to take a realistic and honest look at your finances. Consider the worst that could happen and potential emergency scenarios (for example, an upper respiratory infection affecting every cat in the house, which is not unrealistic or uncommon.) If something like this were to happen how many cats could you provide emergency vet care for? Keep this number in mind – often when emergency vet bills become unmanageable, euthanasia is tragically the only option people are left with.
It’s also important to keep in mind that your vet expenses will likely increase as your cats get older. We can’t be sure what our money situation will be like in five or ten years but we should still do our best to plan for different what-ifs.
Share the love
Beyond financial means, the amount of time you personally can devote to your cats is also an important consideration. While cats may seem to be independent, low maintenance creatures they do require a certain amount of care and attention.
Scooping litter boxes, preparing food, clipping claws, grooming, tooth brushing, administering medication & training all require a time commitment which goes up with each cat. Cats also need individual attention and affection. If you’re at work all day then two cats may be better than one (to keep each other entertained) but you should be able to give each of your cats some one on one petting and play each day. Beyond just basic care, it’s really important that your cats’ emotional and social needs are being met, which for many cats means daily petting and cuddling sessions.
Even if your cats are not affectionate, it’s important to regularly give them individual attention. Only by knowing our cats normal quirks and behaviours on a day to day basis will be able to spot signs of illness and injury while still in their early stages.
Taking care of yourself
In addition to the welfare and well being of your cats, you should also factor in your own well being.
Even the most passionate cat lovers, who have devoted their lives to rescuing cats, need to take care of themselves. Caring for your cats should not prevent you from maintaining your home, holding down a job, having a social life, spending time with friends and family or doing all the other things that healthy human beings do. Just as you enhance the lives of your cats, so should your cats enhance your own life.
Allowing your self to become completely overwhelmed will be detrimental to you and the cats in the long run.Even well meaning people who take on far more cats than they can handle can become so overwhelmed that they lose site of the needs of the individuals in their household, allowing the situation to turn into neglect.
If you share a home with other people, their thoughts and feelings should be considered as well. Not everyone is as passionate about cats as we are, and pets can be a source of stress and resentment for someone who doesn’t want them or like them.
Local by-laws
Expanding beyond your individual circumstances for a moment, we can’t forget local by-laws. Many municipalities have restrictions on the number of pets you can legally keep. Exceeding that number may result in fines or worse. Other areas may not have a restriction on the number of animals you can keep but require that they all be licensed or microchipped.
Before you grow your feline family make sure you’re familiar with the laws in your area. The last thing you want is to grow your joyous feline family only to be forced to break it up or be slapped with big fines.
A note on animal hoarders
Animal hoarding is a tragic situation where a person takes on far more animals than they can care for, usually under the belief that they are rescuing these animals. Animals in hoarding situations are neglected and not cared for properly, often resulting in illness, malnutrition, filthy living conditions, out of control breeding and death, yet the hoarder is unable to recognize and admit that they are incapable of caring for the animals. Animal hoarders tend to become extremely attached to their pets, unwilling to give them up even if it is clearly in the animal’s best interests.
Animal hoarding should not be confused with people who have a large number of cats but who provide proper care for them. It is entirely possible to keep and care for a lots of cats. The OSPCA has more on animal hoarding.
How many cats is right for you?
Adding a new cat to the family should be a carefully considered decision. Being familiar with your living situation will allow you to make an informed decision about the size of your cat family. An abnormal love of cats need not become an unhealthy love of cats. By keeping in mind our current cats, human family, finances, time commitments and local by-laws, we can ensure a happy, healthy feline family, be it large or small.
So how many cats is right for you? Do you plan to add more cats to your household soon, or are you at capacity?
Too Many Cats illustration by Erin Taylor. Please visit her Etsy shop for beautiful prints.
Cat in a cone photo by tray.
Stressed photo by zweettooth.
Cuddly cats photo by ArtBrom.